A rebuttal to ‘Granta’ editor Thomas Meaney’s review of the recently published book Arguments With Gandhi

By Taimur Ali Ahmed / Global Southasia
The Indian public intellectual and historian Ramachandra Guha, author of the definitive two-volume biography of Mahatma Gandhi and one of the finest histories of post-war India, has a new book out titled Arguments With Gandhi published by W. W. Norton & Company on 3 November, 2026. It examines Gandhi’s ideas through his debates with contemporaries and later generations’ arguments over his legacy, exploring questions of nonviolence, caste, religious harmony, and economic justice.
On November 4, The New York Times published a review of Arguments With Gandhi by Thomas Meaney, editor of Granta and a historian, though not someone who specializes in Southasian or Gandhian history.
While he acknowledges that Guha makes a compelling case for Gandhi’s political stature, he portrays Gandhi mostly as a racist, harboring “disgust for Black inhabitants of southern Africa,” who was “horrified to find himself locked up with Black and Chinese prisoners,” and who “fell back on his original sentiments” toward Black people even in his old age.

Worse still, when it came to the caste system in India, Meaney claims, “Gandhi wanted to salvage the caste system, one of the world’s greatest engines for inequality and cruelty,” counseling India’s lowest castes to “embrace their fate” of handling human excrement.
In his critique, Meaney echoes the acclaimed author and political activist Arundhati Roy, who leveled similar accusations in her 2014 polemic, The Doctor and the Saint. Guha had dismantled that critique at length in the second volume of his Gandhi biography.
Both Roy and Meaney frame India’s struggle with its caste system by contrasting Gandhi with his rival, B.R. Ambedkar, the leader from the “untouchable,” or Dalit, caste. While conceding that Gandhi took some action against the caste system and may have had “an element of political pragmatism” in his approach, they see him as an apologist at best and, at worst, prejudiced against Dalits.
What’s missing from Meaney’s essay is context for Gandhi’s position on caste and race. So let’s establish that first.
Gandhi and Ambedkar
For Ambedkar, justice delayed was justice denied. Protecting the Dalits could not wait for a change of heart, and instead required constitutional mechanisms, separate electorates, and the immediate coercive force of law.
Gandhi recognized untouchability as a great evil, too, but he doubted that laws could uproot centuries-old prejudices. He opposed coercion — violence, certainly, but also law imposed on the unwilling.
Fearing that separate electorates would permanently fracture Indian society — as they partially did for Hindus and Muslims — Gandhi sought to shame upper-caste Hindus into reforming their own religion from within, just as he used nonviolence to shame the British Empire into concessions.
Another contrast: Ambedkar embraced secular constitutionalism and saw caste as so integral to Hinduism that scripture itself had to be renounced to rid society of the caste system. Gandhi, hardly orthodox, sought to reform Hinduism from within. This reflected his broader ambition: Independence without cultural imitation.
This confronted a dilemma Ambedkar’s approach couldn’t: What does independence mean if a society abandons its own foundations only to imitate its colonizer? Thus, Gandhi rejected Western industrial materialism and “English rule without the Englishman.” He envisioned India’s villages as the foundation of self-rule and emphasized self-reliance, moral and material restraint. Ambedkar took the opposite view: “What is the village but a sink of localism, a den of ignorance, narrow-mindedness and communalism?”
So, yes, in preserving Indian culture and institutions, Gandhi sought to “salvage” elements of the traditional social order. But preserving is not the same as defending its injustices. His position also evolved. By 1931, he is documented by Guha as saying: “People of different varnas may intermarry and interdine… [A] Brahmin who marries a Sudra girl or vice versa commits no offence against the law of varnas.”
In other words, Gandhi promoted the slow dissolution of inherited class distinctions through intermarriage.
In a way, Ambedkar and Gandhi’s approaches can be summarized as gradualism vs. immediate, legislated change. How much change can be legislated from on high before it polarizes and destabilizes society –perhaps like America?
The deeper question Ambedkar poses to Gandhi is this: Can reform from within dismantle the structure that produced the injustice? Ambedkar’s approach raises a similar question: Can legislation and coercion alone deliver true equality?
As chief architect of India’s 1950 Constitution, Ambedkar abolished untouchability and enshrined anti-caste laws and quotas. Yet seven decades later, because underlying social attitudes were not tackled, those laws have hardly delivered on their promise.
Focused on legislated political and economic change, Ambedkar needed a Gandhi to help complete his mission. And Gandhi, focused on slow, moral change through shaming and persuading, needed an Ambedkar.
Dalit discrimination
To prove Gandhi’s supposed callousness toward Dalits — even in later life — Meaney highlights a single line from a 1936 essay:
“In an essay from 1936 titled ‘The Ideal Bhangi,’ Gandhi suggested that the lower castes tasked with handling the excrement of higher castes — often forced to carry it in baskets on their heads — embrace their fate. ‘An ideal Bhangi,’ Gandhi wrote, ‘should know how to overcome and destroy the odor of excreta and the various disinfectants to render them innocuous.’”
The fuller context of that line is that Gandhi opened “The Ideal Bhangi” by subverting the ritual hierarchy that placed Brahmins above sanitation workers: “The ideal Bhangi of my conception would be a Brahmin par excellence, possibly even excel him.”
“A Bhangi does for society what a mother does for her baby,” he wrote in the same passage. “Just as a mother washes her child to keep it healthy, the sanitation worker “protects and safeguards the health of the entire community.”
Gandhi then condemned the treatment of sanitation workers as social outcasts subjected to “kicks and abuse” and forced to “dwell on the dung-heap,” concluding: “not till the invidious distinction between the Brahmin and the Bhangi is removed will our society enjoy health, prosperity and peace, and be happy.”
Framed against Gandhi’s larger project of reforming Indian society from within, this effort sought to dismantle untouchability using Hinduism’s own moral vocabulary. The sanitation worker was not polluted, but indispensable; the shame belonged entirely to the caste Hindus who degraded him. While the essay admittedly never questions the hereditary assignment of sanitation work, “embrace their fate” is not the central thrust of Gandhi’s essay’. It is the equal moral standing of Bhangi and Brahmin.
Meaney’s portrait misses the scale and heft of Gandhi’s life journey, which tied India’s freedom struggle to Dalit liberation. Among the many actions Gandhi took, the months on the road across India demanding equal access to temples, wells, and schools, braving orthodox fury, stand out — it almost ended his life. A 1934 bomb attack in Poona appears to have been aimed at his car.
Anti-Black prejudice
That the young Gandhi harbored Victorian racial prejudices against Blacks during his early South African years is well established — and documented by Guha himself. The real question is whether the mature Mahatma ever outgrew them.
Dismissing Guha’s argument that Gandhi’s views on Africans evolved over time as only “partly true,” Meaney insists that Gandhi remained prejudiced into old age:
“[A]s late as 1939, for instance, long after he had left behind his lawyer’s three-piece suit for the dhoti and shawl, Gandhi fell back on his original sentiments. ‘However much one may sympathize with the Bantus,’ he wrote, ‘Indians cannot make common cause with them.’”
(“Bantus” was the era’s standard term for indigenous Black South Africans.)
Gandhi’s opposition, however, was to a political merger — not racial bias. Indians were “a microscopic minority” in then-South Africa, he explained in an interview, and a political merger with Africans would pool “not strength but weakness.”
Mixing the two campaigns could only damage and complicate the Africans’ far bigger struggle as well as the Indians’.
Gandhi’s lasting influence on Black Americans also defies Meaney’s portrait of enduring racial bias. The Black press avidly covered his satyagrahas, nonviolent resistance. Civil rights pioneers like Bayard Rustin, who mentored Martin Luther King Jr. in nonviolent resistance, traveled to India to walk in the Mahatma’s footsteps.
In a poignant letter to Gandhi, Black Chicagoan Arthur Sewell linked India’s struggle to those who “mob, lynch and burn us up with fire,” praying for his “glorious victory for the common cause of the lowly.” Reducing the man who inspired Dr. King’s generation to a lifelong racist — even a half-hearted one — is a serious distortion of history.
Meaney concludes by acknowledging that Guha’s book “makes a strong case that Gandhi was one of the greatest political leaders in history,” but adds that “there are harder conversations to be had”, implying that Gandhi’s racism and prejudices need to be confronted.
Yet those harder conversations require wrestling rigorously with a thinker’s evolution, inner tensions, and political realities. By substituting that depth with decontextualized quotes and easy moralizing, The New York Times does its readers — and the historical record — a disservice.
Taimur Ali Ahmed grew up in Lahore and lives in the Bay Area. He posts on X @TaimurAliAhmed and on Substack: @taimuraliahmed.
This is a Global Southasia syndicated feature available for republication with due credit to sapannews.com.
This article was written and edited by humans. Click here for the Global Southasia AI policy.
Why ‘Southasia’ as one word? Because our histories entangle, our struggles intersect, and our futures are bound together.
Appreciated the story? Support non-profit journalism. Make a tax-deductible contribution to Global Southasia.
